The method
How we review.
Our methodology is the product. These are the rules every review, roundup and comparison on Duyan Blog is built on — published so you can check the working or argue with it.
1 · We pick products people actually buy
Review subjects come from reader questions first, market share second, press releases last. Before anything is scheduled we write down the decision a reader is trying to make — “which eSIM for two weeks in Japan” — because that decision, not the product spec sheet, is what the review must settle.
2 · Two names on every review
Every review has a named author who does the research-and-reasoning and a second editor who verifies the claims against the cited sources. Both names appear on the page. If we can't put two names behind a piece, it doesn't run as a review.
3 · Evidence-first: sources and the day we checked
We read the vendor's published pages and the documentation, and we record — for every figure — the URL it came from and the day a human opened it, in the source list at the foot of the page. Where an independent group has measured something, we cite their published result by name.
We do not run our own benchmarks; no page here carries one, and if that ever changes the page will say so. Where a vendor publishes nothing on a point, we leave it empty rather than fill it — a missing row means we did not find it, not that the feature is absent.
4 · Scores map to published criteria
Reviews score a small set of criteria with explicit weights — for software, typically: core experience, performance, value, support and privacy. The overall number is a weighted average of those rows, shown on the page, so you can recompute it or disagree with the weights.
A score without visible criteria is decoration, not review.
5 · Evidence or honesty — never invented numbers
Claims link to sources. When we haven't verified something, we say so plainly instead of producing a plausible-looking statistic. Sample and demo content is labelled as such, everywhere it appears.
We never fabricate research hours, units tested, expert credentials or awards.
6 · Commerce never edits
Merchants and affiliate networks cannot influence scores, rankings or wording. We track this with a simple rule: verdicts are finalised before commission rates are even looked at, and any attempt to change them is published as a correction.
Read the business side in How we make money, and the link rules in the Affiliate disclosure.
7 · Living documents, dated changes
Reviews are revisited when prices, features or our recommendations change. Updated articles carry a new “updated” date and keep their original reporting honest — changes that alter a verdict are noted, not silently smoothed over.
Found a hole in the method?
Good — that's what it's published for. Write to us via the contact form and we'll answer publicly if it changes the rules.